The Barnett
Best for culture-minded travelers and smaller groups who want a neighborhood, music-forward boutique hotel with a rooftop pool and multiple on-site dining options.
Hotel comparison guide
The Barnett vs JW Marriott New Orleans
The Barnett is a 234-room JdV by Hyatt boutique in a restored 1928 Art Deco building, with a heated rooftop pool, five dining venues and near-nightly live music — good for travelers who want a design-forward, locally minded stay. JW Marriott New Orleans is a larger, upscale 4.5-star Marriott on Canal Street with extensive meeting space and full-service hotel amenities — suited to convention attendees and guests who prefer a familiar luxury-brand experience.
Updated · about 0.2 km apart
JW Marriott New Orleans
Best for travelers who want a full-service, branded luxury stay close to Canal Street with extensive meeting and event facilities.
Quick Verdict: The Barnett vs JW Marriott New Orleans
When The Barnett wins: choose The Barnett if you want a stylish boutique stay near the Warehouse Arts District with a heated rooftop pool, intimate restaurants (Seaworthy, Brutto Americano) and an on-site live-music venue. It suits couples, families who want to be near museums and guests after a more local, design-driven experience.
When JW Marriott New Orleans wins: pick the JW Marriott if you need lots of meeting or event space, a central Canal Street address steps from Bourbon Street, and the predictability of a major full-service brand with 501 rooms and plentiful conference rooms.
Bottom line: both hotels put you very close to downtown New Orleans and the French Quarter, but The Barnett is the boutique, locally flavored choice with a rooftop scene; JW Marriott is the bigger, conference-capable, full-service option.
The Barnett vs JW Marriott New Orleans – At a Glance
| Category | The Barnett | JW Marriott New Orleans |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique, design-forward, music and food focused | Upscale, large full-service Marriott on Canal Street |
| Location | Warehouse Arts District; about a 15-minute walk to the French Quarter; near National WWII Museum | Canal Street — steps from Bourbon Street and Royal Street |
| Size | 234 rooms and suites | 501 air-conditioned rooms |
| Rooms (sample naming) | Room, 1 King Bed; Room, 2 Queen Beds; Suite (1 Bedroom); Room, Patio | Deluxe Room, 1 King Bed; Deluxe Room, 2 Queen Beds; Suite, 1 Bedroom, City View |
| Pools | Heated rooftop pool (High Five) open year-round with pool bar and terrace | Access to nearby outdoor pool; pool hoist and wheelchair-accessible pool listed |
| Restaurants & bars | Five venues on site including Seaworthy, Brutto Americano, All Good, The Lobby Bar, High Five | One on-site restaurant and one bar/lounge; room service (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | No named on-site spa published; 24-hour fitness center with Peloton bikes | Not published |
| Meeting & event space | Over 16,000 sq ft across roughly 17 meeting rooms; Barnett Hall (4,000 sq ft) | 23313 sq ft of conference space across 22 meeting rooms |
| Family & age policy | Welcomes children of all ages; primary guest must be 21 to check in | Welcomes all ages (no adults-only policy listed); standard hotel policies apply |
| Accessibility & practical | Wheelchair-accessible rooms and paths, complimentary Wi‑Fi, valet parking (fee) | Wheelchair-accessible paths and meeting spaces, free Wi‑Fi, valet parking (surcharge) |
Location: Warehouse District vs Canal Street
The Barnett – Location
The Barnett sits at 600 Carondelet Street in the Warehouse Arts District, a short walk to museums and Lafayette Square.
- About 15 minutes on foot to the French Quarter and steps from the National WWII Museum.
- St. Charles streetcar access nearby for trips uptown.
- Valet parking only; downtown walkable neighborhood with local restaurants and shops.
Choose The Barnett for a neighborhood stay close to museums and streetcar sightseeing.
JW Marriott New Orleans – Location
JW Marriott New Orleans is on Canal Street at 614 Canal St, in the heart of downtown near Bourbon Street.
- Steps from Canal Street, Bourbon Street and the city’s main downtown attractions.
- Easy walking access to the French Quarter and convention areas.
- Large property footprint on a major downtown thoroughfare.
Pick JW Marriott if you want to be in the busy Canal Street corridor with quick access to Bourbon Street and convention venues.
Rooms: Boutique rooms vs full-service guest rooms
The Barnett – Rooms
The Barnett offers 234 rooms and suites that emphasize historic Art Deco character with modern touches.
- Room types include Room, 1 King Bed; Room, 2 Queen Beds; Suite (1 Bedroom) and patio rooms.
- Complimentary Wi‑Fi throughout the property.
- Room options and public spaces emphasize local design and music programming.
The Barnett’s rooms suit travelers who want boutique design and variety in smaller-room inventory.
JW Marriott New Orleans – Rooms
JW Marriott has 501 air-conditioned rooms across many room types and suites, including Club/Executive options.
- Room types listed include Deluxe Room, 1 King Bed; Premium Room, 1 King Bed, Corner; Suite, 1 Bedroom, City View and many accessible variants.
- Some rooms offer Club Lounge access and Canal Street views.
- Standard full-service conveniences: safes, desks, flat-screen TVs and bathrobes.
JW Marriott is best when you want many room choices, predictable full-service amenities and larger suites.
Dining & drinks: Local flavors vs single restaurant option
The Barnett – Dining & drinks
The Barnett provides five on-site venues spanning seafood, Italian-influenced dinner, an all-day cafe and a rooftop bar.
- Seaworthy serves seafood in a historic Creole cottage with an oyster-focused happy hour.
- Brutto Americano covers brunch and dinner with Italian/Southern influences; All Good New Orleans offers breakfast and lunch.
- High Five rooftop bar serves cocktails and poolside fare; The Lobby Bar offers craft cocktails and small plates.
The Barnett works well for guests who want multiple on-site dining styles and evening live-music programming.
JW Marriott New Orleans – Dining & drinks
JW Marriott lists one on-site restaurant and a bar/lounge, plus room service during limited hours.
- Featured amenities note one restaurant and one bar/lounge on property.
- To-go breakfasts are available for a fee each morning.
- Concierge can assist with off-site dining and local recommendations.
Choose JW Marriott when you prefer a full-service hotel with a single on-site restaurant and concierge-arranged options.
Pools & signature amenity: Rooftop pool vs downtown pool access
The Barnett – Pools & signature amenity
The Barnett’s High Five rooftop pool is a central feature: heated, year-round and paired with a rooftop bar.
- Heated rooftop pool with sun loungers, terrace space and a pool bar; hours and service vary seasonally.
- Pool requires day guests to be 21 or older; hotel guests have access year-round.
- Rooftop includes private cabanas and fire pits during some service hours.
The rooftop pool and bar are The Barnett’s main social amenity for guests and locals alike.
JW Marriott New Orleans – Pools & signature amenity
JW Marriott’s supplier details list access to a nearby outdoor pool and pool accessibility features.
- Listing notes access to a nearby outdoor pool rather than a described on-site heated rooftop pool.
- Pool hoist and wheelchair-accessible pool features are documented.
- Fitness and recreation are available including a 24-hour fitness center.
JW Marriott offers pool access and accessibility features but emphasizes meeting and business facilities over a rooftop social pool.
Wellness & nightlife: Fitness and music vs meetings and business
The Barnett – Wellness & nightlife
The Barnett combines a 24-hour fitness center with near-nightly live music in its Good Measure venue.
- Fitness center open 24 hours with Peloton bikes and free weights.
- Good Measure hosts live music and DJ nights most evenings.
- Nearby museums and walkable neighborhoods add daytime cultural options.
The Barnett blends fitness facilities with an active on-site music calendar for evenings.
JW Marriott New Orleans – Wellness & nightlife
JW Marriott emphasizes business and conference facilities along with full-service hotel amenities.
- Large amount of conference space (23313 sq ft) and 22 meeting rooms.
- 24-hour fitness facilities and concierge services are available.
- Hotel lists wedding services and business-center features.
JW Marriott fits business travelers and groups who need meeting infrastructure alongside fitness options.
Who Wins? Best Pick by Travel Style
The Barnett
The Barnett — on-site Good Measure venue with near-nightly performances and a lively rooftop bar.
JW Marriott New Orleans
JW Marriott New Orleans — over 23,000 sq ft of conference space and 22 meeting rooms for large events.
The Barnett
The Barnett — five distinct on-site dining venues including Seaworthy and Brutto Americano in a restored 1928 building.
JW Marriott New Orleans
JW Marriott New Orleans — large property with full-service amenities, concierge and rooms that include Club/Executive options.
Frequently asked questions
See all FAQs →The Barnett vs JW Marriott New Orleans: FAQs
Which hotel is closer to Bourbon Street and Canal Street?
JW Marriott New Orleans is right on Canal Street and steps from Bourbon Street; The Barnett is a short walk from those areas in the Warehouse District.
Which hotel has a rooftop pool?
The Barnett has a heated rooftop pool (High Five) open year-round. JW Marriott’s listing notes access to a nearby outdoor pool but does not describe a named rooftop pool.
Which is better for meetings or a convention block?
JW Marriott New Orleans — it has significantly larger conference capacity (about 23,313 sq ft across 22 meeting rooms). The Barnett also offers event space (over 16,000 sq ft) but on a smaller scale.
Are either of these adults-only properties?
No — both properties welcome guests of all ages, though The Barnett requires the primary check-in guest to be at least 21.
More The Barnett Comparison Guides
Explore how The Barnett stacks up against other hotels nearby:
- The Barnett vs The Ritz-Carlton, New Orleans
- The Barnett vs Four Seasons Hotel New Orleans
- The Barnett vs The Roosevelt New Orleans, A Waldorf Astoria Hotel
- The Barnett vs The Windsor Court
- The Barnett vs Hotel Monteleone, New Orleans
- The Barnett vs The Royal Sonesta New Orleans
- The Barnett vs Omni Royal Orleans Hotel
- The Barnett vs Hilton New Orleans Riverside
- The Barnett vs Hyatt Regency New Orleans
- The Barnett vs Bourbon Orleans Hotel
- The Barnett vs The Westin New Orleans
- The Barnett vs Le Pavillon, New Orleans, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel
- The Barnett vs Virgin Hotels New Orleans
- The Barnett vs Hotel Saint Vincent
- The Barnett vs Loews New Orleans Hotel
- The Barnett vs Hyatt Centric French Quarter New Orleans
- The Barnett vs The Eliza Jane, Autograph Collection
- The Barnett vs Hotel Peter and Paul, an Ash Hotel
- All The Barnett comparisons
Book your stay
Rooftop Pool & High Five Bar
- Lowest rate guarantee
- Complimentary perks & upgrades
- 24/7 concierge