The Barnett
Best for guests who want multiple on-site dining options, regular live music, a heated rooftop pool, and extensive event/meeting space.
Hotel comparison guide
The Barnett vs Hotel Saint Vincent
The Barnett is a 234-room JdV by Hyatt boutique in a restored 1928 Art Deco building, aimed at adults but welcoming families and groups. Hotel Saint Vincent is a stylish 4.5-star boutique in the Lower Garden District for travelers focused on design, dining, and a lively local scene — read this if you want to compare food, rooftop pools, and location between two fashionable New Orleans options.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart
Hotel Saint Vincent
Best for travelers seeking a smaller, design-forward boutique with on-site Mediterranean dining and a quieter Lower Garden District address close to Magazine Street.
Quick Verdict: The Barnett vs Hotel Saint Vincent
When The Barnett wins: choose The Barnett if you want more on-site variety — five food-and-drink venues, a music venue with near-nightly programming, a larger room inventory (useful for groups and wedding blocks), and a heated rooftop pool with a full rooftop bar.
When Hotel Saint Vincent wins: choose Hotel Saint Vincent if you prefer a smaller boutique property in the Lower Garden District steps from Magazine Street, with Mediterranean dining (San Lorenzo) and a quieter neighborhood vibe for strolling local shops and cafes.
Bottom line: both hotels put you within easy reach of New Orleans attractions but serve different traveler priorities — The Barnett for scale, dining variety, and events; Hotel Saint Vincent for a compact, design-focused stay near Magazine Street.
The Barnett vs Hotel Saint Vincent – At a Glance
| Category | The Barnett | Hotel Saint Vincent |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large Art Deco boutique that mixes modern programming (live music, rooftop scene) with historic architecture | Stylish, smaller boutique focused on design and neighborhood dining in the Lower Garden District |
| Location | Warehouse District / near Lafayette Square; ~15-minute walk to the French Quarter; on the St. Charles streetcar route | Lower Garden District, steps from Magazine Street and neighborhood shopping/dining |
| Size (rooms) | 234 rooms and suites | 75 rooms |
| Adults policy | All ages welcome; primary check-in guest must be at least 21 | |
| Pools | One heated rooftop outdoor pool with sun loungers and a rooftop bar (High Five) | One outdoor pool (pool access ramp noted); accessible pool features listed |
| Restaurants & bars | Five on-site venues including Seaworthy, Brutto Americano, All Good New Orleans, The Lobby Bar and High Five rooftop | Two restaurants including San Lorenzo (Mediterranean) plus cafe and two bars/lounges |
| Spa / wellness | 24-hour fitness center with Peloton bikes; spa treatments described via local providers but no named on-site spa | Spa services on site listed, but a dedicated on-site spa name is Not published |
| Known for | Live-music programming (Good Measure), rooftop pool/bar, and event capacity (weddings & meetings) | Fashionable boutique design, neighborhood location next to Magazine Street, San Lorenzo restaurant |
| Event & meeting space | Over 16,000 sq ft of event space with Barnett Hall (4,000 sq ft) and many meeting rooms | Number of meeting rooms listed as 2 and smaller meeting/event capacity |
| On-site accessibility features | Accessible rooms and features noted (accessible registration, elevator width, etc.) | Extensive accessibility features listed (accessible parking, pool hoist, accessible restaurant and registration) |
Location: Warehouse District vs Lower Garden District
The Barnett – Location
The Barnett sits in the Warehouse Arts District/CBD within easy walking distance of key downtown sites.
- About a 15-minute walk to the French Quarter and close to the National WWII Museum and Lafayette Square.
- Direct access to the St. Charles Avenue streetcar nearby for trips into the Garden District and Uptown.
- Blocks from Caesars Superdome and downtown business/entertainment destinations.
Choose The Barnett if you want central downtown access and easy transit into other city neighborhoods.
Hotel Saint Vincent – Location
Hotel Saint Vincent is in the Lower Garden District, a short walk to Magazine Street's shops and restaurants.
- Steps from Magazine Street and neighborhood cafes, shops, and galleries.
- Approximately 0.7 mi (1.1 km) from the National WWII Museum and within easy taxi or streetcar distance to the French Quarter.
- Quieter residential streets compared with downtown Warehouse District traffic.
Choose Hotel Saint Vincent for a quieter, neighborhood-first stay with Magazine Street within easy reach.
Rooms: inventory & character
The Barnett – Rooms
The Barnett offers a large selection of room types across 234 rooms and suites in a restored 1928 building.
- 234 guest rooms and suites blending historical Art Deco architecture with modern design.
- Room types include multiple suites and patio/corner room options useful for groups and families.
- Complimentary Wi‑Fi in rooms and premium bedding with memory foam mattresses noted.
The Barnett suits travelers who want a variety of room options and lots of inventory for group bookings.
Hotel Saint Vincent – Rooms
Hotel Saint Vincent is a smaller boutique with a curated set of room types (75 rooms total).
- Room types include Superior Suite; Studio (Sister); several king and queen room variants and named suites (Veranda, Mary).
- Designer toiletries and minibars are noted; rooms are air-conditioned and include LED TVs.
- Complimentary Wi‑Fi and premium bedding also listed.
Hotel Saint Vincent works well if you prefer a smaller property with boutique, design-forward rooms.
Dining & drinks: five venues vs focused restaurants
The Barnett – Dining & drinks
The Barnett emphasizes on-site variety with five distinct food and drink venues and live music options.
- Seaworthy (seafood in a Creole cottage) and Brutto Americano (Italian/Southern) are signature outlets.
- All Good New Orleans cafe for breakfast and grab-and-go items plus The Lobby Bar for cocktails.
- High Five rooftop serves pool-side fare and cocktails; Good Measure hosts near-nightly performances.
The Barnett is preferable if you want multiple on-site dining and nightlife options without leaving the hotel.
Hotel Saint Vincent – Dining & drinks
Hotel Saint Vincent focuses on curated dining with two restaurants and two bars/lounges.
- San Lorenzo is a Mediterranean restaurant highlighted as a property signature.
- Room service available during limited hours and a coffee shop/cafe on-site for snacks.
- Two bars/lounges give guests options for drinks without an extensive outlet list.
Pick Hotel Saint Vincent for concentrated, design-centric dining and easy access to Magazine Street's restaurants.
Pools & rooftop scene
The Barnett – Pools & rooftop scene
The Barnett's heated rooftop pool and High Five rooftop bar are central to its social scene.
- Heated outdoor rooftop pool open year-round with sun loungers, terrace space and greenery.
- High Five pool bar offers seasonal food, signature cocktails, cabanas and fire pits.
- Pool is a social spot linked to the hotel's live-music programming and rooftop events.
The rooftop pool is a key feature at The Barnett for guests seeking an active hotel social life.
Hotel Saint Vincent – Pools & rooftop scene
Hotel Saint Vincent lists an outdoor pool and accessible pool features among its amenities.
- One outdoor pool is listed along with pool access ramp and pool hoist on site.
- Pool-related accessibility features are emphasized in the property listing.
- Pool is part of the hotel's boutique amenity set rather than a large rooftop scene.
Hotel Saint Vincent provides pool access with strong accessibility features but not the large rooftop scene of The Barnett.
Wellness & nightlife
The Barnett – Wellness & nightlife
The Barnett pairs a 24-hour fitness center with frequent on-site live music and evening programming.
- 24-hour fitness center equipped with Peloton bikes, cardio machines, and weights.
- Good Measure music venue offers near-nightly performances, from jazz sessions to DJs.
- Spa treatments are arranged via local providers rather than a named on-site spa.
The Barnett blends fitness access with a steady entertainment program for evening plans on property.
Hotel Saint Vincent – Wellness & nightlife
Hotel Saint Vincent lists spa services on site and a quieter bar/restaurant-driven evening scene.
- Spa services are noted in the property's amenities list, though a named in-house spa is Not published.
- Two bars/lounges provide evening drink options without extensive nightly programming listed.
- Concierge and tours/ticket assistance support local outings and neighborhood discovery.
Hotel Saint Vincent is a calmer evening choice focused on dining and neighborhood exploration rather than nightly music programming.
Who Wins? Best Pick by Travel Style
The Barnett
The Barnett — heated rooftop pool with a full rooftop bar (High Five) and regular live-music programming.
Hotel Saint Vincent
Hotel Saint Vincent — smaller boutique in the Lower Garden District steps from Magazine Street.
The Barnett
The Barnett — over 16,000 sq ft of event space and a large largest room (Barnett Hall) for conferences and weddings.
Hotel Saint Vincent
Hotel Saint Vincent — a focused restaurant offering (San Lorenzo) and two bars in a compact boutique setting.
Frequently asked questions
See all FAQs →The Barnett vs Hotel Saint Vincent: FAQs
Which hotel is better for a weekend focused on restaurants and neighborhood shops?
Hotel Saint Vincent — it's steps from Magazine Street's cafes, boutiques, and galleries, making it convenient for a neighborhood-focused weekend.
Which hotel is better for a group or wedding block?
The Barnett — with 234 rooms and more than 16,000 sq ft of event space (including Barnett Hall), it has larger inventory and event capacity.
Do either property’s pools require day-pass minimum ages?
The Barnett's rooftop pool has day-guest age restrictions (non-hotel day guests must be 21+); Hotel Saint Vincent lists accessible pool features but does not publish a day-guest age policy in the supplied listing.
Are on-site spas available at both hotels?
Both properties list wellness services; however, a named, dedicated on-site spa is Not published for Hotel Saint Vincent and The Barnett arranges treatments through local providers rather than a confirmed in-house spa name.
More The Barnett Comparison Guides
Explore how The Barnett stacks up against other hotels nearby:
- The Barnett vs The Ritz-Carlton, New Orleans
- The Barnett vs Four Seasons Hotel New Orleans
- The Barnett vs The Roosevelt New Orleans, A Waldorf Astoria Hotel
- The Barnett vs The Windsor Court
- The Barnett vs Hotel Monteleone, New Orleans
- The Barnett vs The Royal Sonesta New Orleans
- The Barnett vs Omni Royal Orleans Hotel
- The Barnett vs JW Marriott New Orleans
- The Barnett vs Hilton New Orleans Riverside
- The Barnett vs Hyatt Regency New Orleans
- The Barnett vs Bourbon Orleans Hotel
- The Barnett vs The Westin New Orleans
- The Barnett vs Le Pavillon, New Orleans, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel
- The Barnett vs Virgin Hotels New Orleans
- The Barnett vs Loews New Orleans Hotel
- The Barnett vs Hyatt Centric French Quarter New Orleans
- The Barnett vs The Eliza Jane, Autograph Collection
- The Barnett vs Hotel Peter and Paul, an Ash Hotel
- All The Barnett comparisons
Book your stay
Rooftop Pool & High Five Bar
- Lowest rate guarantee
- Complimentary perks & upgrades
- 24/7 concierge