
The Barnett
Best for culture-focused travelers and small groups who want a modern, music-forward hotel near museums and streetcar access.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Barnett is a 234-room JdV by Hyatt boutique in a restored 1928 Art Deco building in the Warehouse District with a heated rooftop pool and multiple on-site restaurants; read this if you want a design-forward, music-friendly downtown base close to museums. Hotel Monteleone is a historic 4-star French Quarter property with roughly 570 guestrooms, a full-service spa and a long-standing carousel bar; read this if you prefer staying in the heart of the Quarter and value history and on-site event space.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for culture-focused travelers and small groups who want a modern, music-forward hotel near museums and streetcar access.

Best for travelers who want a classic French Quarter stay with extensive meeting space, a full-service spa, and central access to Bourbon Street and Jackson Square.
When The Barnett wins: choose The Barnett if you want a smaller, design-forward property with a heated rooftop pool, regular live-music programming, and five distinct on-site dining options within easy walking distance of Warehouse District attractions.
When Hotel Monteleone wins: choose Hotel Monteleone if you want to be in the center of the French Quarter, need lots of meeting or event space, or prefer a large, historic hotel with a recognized on-site bar and a full-service spa.
Bottom line: The Barnett is a contemporary, mid-size option for guests who prioritize local dining, rooftop pool time, and a Warehouse District location; Hotel Monteleone is a larger, historically significant French Quarter hotel better suited to visitors who want classic Quarter atmosphere, extensive event facilities, and a full-service spa.
| Category | The Barnett | Hotel Monteleone, New Orleans |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Art Deco boutique, modern design, music-forward | Historic French Quarter landmark, traditional luxury |
| Location | Warehouse District / near museums and St. Charles streetcar | French Quarter, steps from Bourbon Street and Jackson Square |
| Size (rooms) | 234 rooms and suites | 570 guestrooms |
| Family policy / age | All ages welcome; primary check-in guest must be 21+ | All ages welcome; primary check-in age minimum not published here |
| Pools | One heated rooftop pool (year-round) with pool bar | One outdoor pool and poolside bar |
| Restaurants & bars | Five on-site dining/drink venues (Seaworthy, Brutto Americano, All Good, Lobby Bar, High Five) | One main restaurant (Criollo), plus bar/lounge and poolside bar |
| Spa & fitness | 24-hour fitness center with Peloton bikes; no named on-site spa published | Full-service spa, health club on site |
| Meeting & event space | Over 16,000 sq ft of event space; Barnett Hall 4,000 sq ft | About 24,003 sq ft of conference/meeting space and a ballroom |
| Known for | Rooftop pool, live music venue Good Measure, and Seaworthy in a Creole cottage | Movie-history and literary ties, Carousel Bar, central French Quarter location |
The Barnett sits at 600 Carondelet Street in the Warehouse District, minutes from museums and the St. Charles streetcar.
Choose The Barnett for museum- and streetcar-oriented access and a slightly quieter downtown base.
Hotel Monteleone is at 214 Royal Street in the center of the French Quarter, steps from Bourbon Street and Jackson Square.
Choose Hotel Monteleone to be in the middle of French Quarter sights and nightlife.
The Barnett has 234 rooms and suites in a restored 1928 Art Deco building, blending vintage architecture with modern interiors.
The Barnett offers a compact inventory with design-led rooms and several suite/patio options.
Hotel Monteleone offers a large range of room types across a sizable historic property, with roughly 570 guestrooms.
Hotel Monteleone suits guests who want many room-type choices and larger historic suites.
The Barnett provides five on-site dining and drinking spots covering seafood, Italian, cafe fare, a lobby bar and a rooftop venue.
The Barnett is the better choice for guests who want multiple, varied on-site dining options without leaving the hotel.
Hotel Monteleone has Criollo Restaurant plus a bar/lounge and poolside bar; its dining program supports a classic French Quarter stay.
Hotel Monteleone is a good match for travelers who want classic Quarter dining and convenient room service rather than many on-site concepts.
The Barnett’s rooftop High Five pool is a defining feature—heated, open year-round, with sun loungers and poolside service.
Pick The Barnett if a heated rooftop pool and downtown views are priorities.
Hotel Monteleone lists one outdoor pool and a poolside bar as part of its on-site recreational features.
Hotel Monteleone offers a traditional hotel pool plus the historical draw of the Carousel Bar.
The Barnett covers fitness, live music and easy access to local nightlife from its Warehouse District base.
The Barnett works well if you want in-house music programming plus round-the-clock fitness.
Hotel Monteleone provides a full-service spa and sits amid French Quarter nightlife and late-night entertainment.
Choose Monteleone for on-site spa treatments and immediate access to French Quarter nightlife.

The Barnett — heated rooftop pool with sun terrace, bar service and skyline views.

Hotel Monteleone — steps from Bourbon Street, Jackson Square and Royal Street shopping.

Hotel Monteleone — roughly 24,003 sq ft of conference and meeting space including a ballroom.

The Barnett — five distinct dining and drinking venues covering seafood, Italian, cafe and rooftop bar.
Hotel Monteleone is located in the French Quarter, a short walk to Bourbon Street; The Barnett is about a 15-minute walk away in the Warehouse District.
Both hotels have extensive meeting space; Hotel Monteleone lists about 24,003 sq ft while The Barnett offers over 16,000 sq ft with a 4,000 sq ft Barnett Hall.
The Barnett’s rooftop pool is heated and operated year-round; Hotel Monteleone lists an outdoor pool (confirm current seasonal hours with the hotel).
Hotel Monteleone publishes a full-service spa on site; The Barnett lists fitness facilities but does not publish a named on-site spa.
Explore how The Barnett stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·